Registry Tampa Bay

Part beach bar off the beach, part fish shack, Trophy Fish is one of the more unique restaurants along St. Pete’s Central Avenue. The open-air space is surrounded by a tall shrub, with a single entrance. The sign is small and unlit. Overall, the place has a shaggy charm that I dig.

With Bonnie on a gals’ trip, my close friend and regular FFF consultant, David Downing, joined me for dinner at 7 p.m. Friday.

David and I sat at a four-top under the stars as the beginnings of a cold front moved through. Barely jacket weather, but I’ll use any excuse.

At Trophy Fish, you order drinks at the covered bar in the middle of the courtyard and meals at a window near the back, where a chalkboard lists the fish on offer. On this evening it was Mahi and Lane Snapper. You then choose your seasoning and sauce.

We split two meals: the Mahi (blackened, $27.50) and the Lane Snapper (citrus rub, $30.50), which included a total of four sides. We chose Pineapple Cabbage Slaw, Chorizo Creamed Corn, Trophy Taters and Seasonal Vegetables (green beans).

I had a draft and David a glass of Chardonnay while we waited for the delivery of our meals. Per FFF convention, I’ll pick a favorite at the end.

Appearance

The unfussy presentation was in keeping with the Trophy Fish concept. The Mahi is directly above. The snapper is the lead photo (by David).

Taste and Texture

Trophy Fish states plainly that it serves “catch(es)-of-the-day,” and these filets tasted like it. The mahi had a meatier texture and a more potent flavor than the snapper, which had a more mild, melt-in-your-mouth quality. I need to remember to order “extra-” or well-blackened” because the mahi could’ve used some more zing. The citrus rub was fairly mild as well.

All of the sides were tasty, but David and I both agreed that the Chorizo Creamed Corn was the standout. Corn flavor held sway over the chorizo, which was more of an accent. The potatoes looked like a pile of brown lumps, but they had a surprising tenderness and a hearty flavor.

Now to (both of our) Our Favorites:

Fish — Mahi
Side — Chorizo Creamed Corn

In all, dining with a friend at Trophy Fish proved to be a lovely outing on a lovely Friday night.

 

Photo by David Downing

 

 

Share this with friends.

Planning an Event?

Join Our Community Calendar!

Promote your events on our Community Calendar